Best K Cup Coffee

14 Best K Cup Coffee Options in 2021

Did you just buy a new Keurig machine and are just dying to know the best K Cup coffee flavors? Or are just simply looking for some new K Cup flavors to try? Well, lucky for you, we have compiled a list of our all-time favorite K Cup flavors from a range of different roasts and blends. If you are a coffee lover, you will just love our top 14 picks for the best K Cup coffee. 

Top 14 Best K Cup Coffee Options

Brand
Best Overall
Café Bustelo
Favorite flavor
CINNABON
Most Classic
The Original Donut Shop
Caribou Coffee
Café Escapes
Flavor
Espresso, Dark-Roast
Classic Cinnamon Roll, Light-Roast
Regular, Medium Roast
Medium Roast
Café Mocha
Caffeinated
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes, < 50 mg
Unique Features
Recyclable
Certified Orthodox Union Kosher
Recyclable and Orthodox Union Kosher
Notes of berry, spice, and cocoa
Contains Milk
Price
$48.50
$29.84
$32.34
$32.34
$51.00
Prime Status
Best Overall
Brand
Café Bustelo
Flavor
Espresso, Dark-Roast
Caffeinated
Yes
Unique Features
Recyclable
Price
$48.50
Prime Status
Button
Favorite flavor
Brand
CINNABON
Flavor
Classic Cinnamon Roll, Light-Roast
Caffeinated
Yes
Unique Features
Certified Orthodox Union Kosher
Price
$29.84
Prime Status
Button
Most Classic
Brand
The Original Donut Shop
Flavor
Regular, Medium Roast
Caffeinated
Yes
Unique Features
Recyclable and Orthodox Union Kosher
Price
$32.34
Prime Status
Button
Brand
Caribou Coffee
Flavor
Medium Roast
Caffeinated
Yes
Unique Features
Notes of berry, spice, and cocoa
Price
$32.34
Prime Status
Button
Brand
Café Escapes
Flavor
Café Mocha
Caffeinated
Yes, < 50 mg
Unique Features
Contains Milk
Price
$51.00
Prime Status
Button

1. Café Bustelo Espresso-Style Dark Roast

Café Bustelo’s Espresso-style dark roast, a well-known Latin coffee brand, has K-Cups for you to brew at home. This is one of the best options for espresso and dark-roast flavored coffee. Modern kitchenware brews Café Bustelo’s coffee with traditional flavors and will fill your kitchen with its strong aroma. If this coffee appeals to you, keep your eye out for the bright yellow packaging, and enjoy your espresso-style Café Bustelo coffee!

Specifications

  • Dark Roast
  • Caffeinated
  • Espresso-style coffee

Sample Customer Review…  I use Café Bustelo in a Keurig machine for my one, two, some days -even a third cup of coffee! I’ve been drinking it for about two years now, and have run out of it a couple of times, which proves each time that Café Bustle truly is my absolute favorite coffee! It’s never bitter or “off” tasting in any way. I love trying new things, and have tried many blends of coffee…just because, but always come right back to this coffee. I recommend it to All!

Read more reviews at Amazon.com

2. Caribou Coffee Caribou Blend 

The Caribou Blend, crafted from Indonesian Beans, incorporates a multitude of flavor components, including notes of woody and spice flavors topped with a touch of dark chocolate. The Caribou Coffee Caribou Blend is full-bodied, making it more of a dark medium blend. Each sip is packed with a bold flavor, which in turn, intensifies your craving for wanting more. 

Specifications

  • Medium Roast
  • Notes of berry and sweet spicy
  • Caffeinated
  • Kosher-Certified

Sample Customer Review… Let me start by saying I am a huge coffee snob. I am super picky about my coffee. I want it to be smooth and flavorful and not too bitter or sour tasting. In addition, I heavily rely on coffee to wake me up and bring me joy in the morning. Haha! I drink at least two cups every day. I have tried countless brands and flavors of coffee and this is by far the most consistent and delicious coffee I have ever had!

I used to change it up nearly every time I shopped because I just wasn’t satisfied, but after discovering this a little over a year ago, I haven’t tried anything else. I hope this is never discontinued because I truly don’t know what I would do without it.

Read more reviews at Amazon.com

3. Cinnabon Classic Cinnamon Rolls Blend

Do you love to add a sprinkle of cinnamon to everything? Well, then you will love the Cinnabon Classic Cinnamon Rolls K-Cups. These K-Cups are a lighter roast, making them not too sweet, yet, also bold and smooth in flavor. Every sip includes touches of cinnamon, brown sugar, and the delicious taste of frosting. This K-Cup blend has easily become a fan-favorite, making it a perfect option throughout the day! 

Specifications

  • Light Roast
  • Hints of cinnamon, brown sugar, & frosting
  • Caffeinated
  • Kosher-Certified 

Sample Customer Review… I love cinnamon and used to buy cinnamon-flavored coffee beans. When we began using our Keurig, I noticed the K-cups in a cinnamon flavor. Had to try it and decided on the Cinnabon brand. Wow, so glad I bought it. It has a true cinnamon flavor and I highly recommend it for other cinnamon fans. I also like the fact that the flavor is pure cinnamon instead of another flavor such as vanilla, hazelnut, etc.
Try it. I think you will be pleased with its excellent flavor.

Read more reviews at Amazon.com

4. Cafe Escapes Cafe Mocha

Cafe Escapes’ Cafe-Mocha K-Cups are the perfect coffee drink for chocolate lovers and those who don’t enjoy strong, bitter flavors early in the morning. Cocoa and coffee balance each other out, creating a smooth, creamy, hot-chocolate flavored cup of coffee. Unlike many flavored K-Cups, these Cafe-Mochas don’t fall to the depths of weak coffee. The Cafe Escapes Cafe-Mocha blends the perfect mix of bitter and sweet. These single-serving K-Cups can replace morning trips to the coffee shop without sacrificing a strong and flavorful cup of chocolate-flavored coffee.  

Specifications

  • Chocolate, Mocha flavors
  • Caffeinated
  • Contains Milk

Sample Customer Review…I love it; very tasty – nothing strange or weird to me. I still sometimes dress it up with coffee creamer and whipping cream for an indulgence. but it is very good all by itself. on the one hand, I think it is pricey but then again it beats the hell out of coffee shop prices and totally satisfies my chocolate and caffeine need. It also has less caffeine than my regular cup; so that’s a good thing. I can have this in the afternoon.

Read more reviews at Amazon.com

5. The Original Donut Shop Regular

Are you looking for a perfect everyday darker medium blend that’s not quite as bitter as some other ones? Well, the Original Donut Shop Regular Blend is strong and full-bodied, yet, not overly bitter or acidic. Each sip packs a punch with a multitude of flavors, including cherry, chocolate, cedar, & black currant. This K-Cup blend is perfect for a morning brew, or for any time of the day! 

Specifications

  • Medium Roast
  • Notes of cherry, chocolate, cedar, & black currant
  • Caffeinated
  • Kosher-Certified

Sample Customer Review… I’ve never considered myself a coffee connoisseur by any means. One coffee tasted like the next to me. I’ve always purchased different brands hoping that one would stand out from the rest and finally I have found that brand! This coffee has a wonderful aroma while brewing which made me salivate just smelling it. The first sip all the way to the last sip was excellent. It has a smooth flavor without an overbearing bitter taste. I am now a dedicated Donut Shop coffee fan! Finally, I found a coffee that stands out from the rest!

Read more reviews at Amazon.com

6. Dunkin’ Original Blend

Are you looking for a blend that is not quite as strong as a darker roast, but has more body than a lighter roast? Perhaps, you should consider the Dunkin’ Original Blend. This K-Cup blend is beloved by many for its balance of caffeine and smooth flavor in every sip. Its unique and memorable flavor includes hints of maple, toffee, lemongrass, and an array of baking spices. 

Specifications

  • Medium Roast
  • Notes of maple, toffee, lemongrass, & baking spices
  • Caffeinated

Sample Customer Reviews… “I love to be able to pop a Dunkin Donuts K cup into my Keurig in the morning and have my house smell like Dunkin! I wouldn’t change this product. I think it has a delicious flavor, if only I could make my coffee how the restaurant does. I would highly recommend this!”

“The taste of these coffee pods is very consistent. I like using the medium roast because I can add any flavor I want to it and it still has a nice coffee taste. These are very easy to use. Good product!”

Reviews from Dunkinathome.com

7. Green Mountain Breakfast Blend 

If you are looking for a lighter roast that can still boost your energy up in the morning, then the Green Mountain Breakfast Blend might be the perfect staple K-Cup to add to your daily morning routine. This K-Cup offers a dynamic and robust taste with notes of a sweet and nutty combination. Overall, this K-Cup blend is a great everyday option! 

Specifications

  • Light Roast
  • Nutty & sweet taste
  • Caffeinated
  • Kosher-Certified

Sample Customer Review… Probably my go-to flavor for both hot and iced coffee. Breakfast Blend and Our Blend are basically interchangeable and I couldn’t pick them out of a lineup. I also like Vermont Country Blend, which is medium and a tad richer.

Breakfast and Our Blends are light roasts, easy on the stomach, and not for people who like burnt or dark coffees. I like my coffee light and this is perfect for me.

Read more reviews at Amazon.com

8. Starbucks Dark French Roast

The Starbucks Dark French Roast is not only the darkest Starbucks’ roast but also one of the best overall dark roasts on the market. Hence, we just had to include it on our list. The blend is a standout for its smokiness flavor and low acidic content, along with its lighter body in comparison to other dark roasts. Overall, these K-Cups perfectly balance the intense flavor of a typical dark roast with a soft finish, maximizing the consumption experience. 

Specifications

  • Dark Roast
  • Robust & bold taste
  • Caffeinated

Sample Customer Review… In my opinion, this is the best of Starbucks’ variety of roasts, that is to say, if you prefer a dark roasted, fuller flavor of the coffee. I know a lot of people complain (myself included) about Starbucks coffee being too “burnt” in taste, and that’s simply because Starbucks roasts its coffee beans much longer than the industry standard (I used to work in a related industry). Consequently, you’re left with a fuller-flavored and more robust taste. Personally, I prefer this French roast over anything else Starbucks produces—in fact, it’s the only Starbucks coffee I will buy. So, if you enjoy darker roasted coffee, give this a try—I think you’ll be pleasantly surprised.

Read more reviews at Amazon.com

9. Gevalia Colombian Blend

The Gevalia Colombian Blend is bound to be a great brew considering it comes from Sweden, one of the world’s largest coffee consumers and manufacturers. The coffee blend embodies the Swedish brewing and roasting traditions of over 150 years. These pods use only the finest arabica coffee blends, ensuring a premium and rich-tasting cup of joe. Each cup will deliver a bright-tasting and medium-bodied brew in combination with a captivating flavor that is paired seemingly with the roast level. The Colombian blend features a strong element of sweet caramel mixed with a slight hint of citrus. 

Specifications

  • Medium Roast
  • Rich & bright taste
  • Caffeinated
  • Kosher-Certified

Sample Customer Review… All I can say is “wow!” I purchased a Keurig 1 year ago and have experimented with various coffee K- cups including Dunkin Donuts, McDonald’s, Cafe Bustelo, and Starbucks…this is by far the strongest, smoothest, and most flavorful K-cup! I want my coffee to taste like coffee, to be strong yet tasteful, this is it!! I don’t add cream or sugar to my coffee due to unwanted excess calories, I only add whole milk. Thank you for creating such a great line of coffee; as a future doctor…..in 12 days (yay), I believe I have discovered my coffee of choice throughout my upcoming career…..Thank you!

Read more reviews at Amazon.com

10. Dunkin’ French Vanilla

The Dunkin’ French Vanilla, similar to the Original Blend, is full-bodied and strong in flavor. The French Vanilla taste shines through without being too sweet, while still offering a soft and harmonious blend of flavors in each sip. The medium blend offers a perfectly balanced amount of caffeine to help keep you energized throughout the day. Overall, this K-Cup is delicious and bold, making it ideal for any morning! 

Specifications

  • Medium Roast
  • Notes of vanilla 
  • Caffeinated

Sample Customer Reviews… “This coffee is always the same, not too strong and not too weak. I like it because the vanilla flavor does not overpower the coffee. You know what you’ll get when you order Dunkin’ Donuts coffee.”

“DD French Vanilla is always the same – dependable and yummy. It’s my first coffee of the morning and, if I want a second cup, it’s DD French Vanilla again!”

Read more reviews at Amazon.com

11. Swiss Miss Milk Chocolate Hot Cocoa

While Swiss Miss Hot Chocolate is not coffee, we just had to include these! There is nothing more comforting than snuggling up in a blanket by a fire with a cup of hot chocolate on a cold winter day. These Swiss Miss K-Cups deliver a rich, creamy, and authentic hot chocolate taste in a matter of just seconds on your Keurig machine! But not only does Swiss Miss offer the classic milk chocolate flavor, but they also come in peppermint and reduced-calorie! Plus, these K-Cups are family-friendly, and if you have children they will love these! 

Specifications

  • Hot Cocoa
  • Hints of sweet & milk chocolate

Sample Customer Review… The best choice! We have done the pricey brands,“ Gourmet Cocoa” etc.. but they all bombed flavor-wise! If you want the best Cocoa for Kuerig type… hands down go with Swiss Miss! The only way to get true cocoa is to do it with milk on the stove.. old-fashioned way!! But if you’re looking for a quick & easy cup don’t waste $$ on Starbucks or other “gourmet” brands cuz you’ll be disappointed!! Swiss Misswill give you the best Cocoa every time! Throw a few mini marshmallows in for a trip back to your childhood !!

Read more reviews at Amazon.com

12. Peet’s Café Domingo

Peet’s Coffee’s reputation for delivering high-quality coffee and blends already speaks volumes for their K-Cups. But we can ensure you that the Café Domingo K-Cups will blow your socks off! It features medium roast perfection, along with a soft and balanced taste to impress most coffee drinkers. Within each cup, you will taste touches of chocolates and nuts enforced by a hint of sweet caramel. Whether you want a new go-to cup of coffee or a special blend to add to your collection, then you should consider purchasing the Café Domingo K-Cups. 

Specifications

  • Medium Roast
  • Nutty taste
  • Caffeinated
  • Kosher-Certified

Sample Customer Review… The Peet’s name was introduced to us before K-Cups, and we liked it a lot. Now we have a Keurig, and Peet’s Cafe Domingo is all we buy. Its price is slightly higher than others, the coffee content per cup is significantly higher (thus the ‘stronger’ taste mentioned by some – if you find it too strong, get a bigger coffee cup and pic a larger cup setting on your Keurig). Most importantly the coffee produced by these k-cups is far superior in taste (at least to my wife, myself, and everyone we’ve shared it with,) to anything else available in the grocery stores, and all but the most expensive stuff available online,(and it seems to us to be better than many of those expensive brands!). Wait for a sale at a supermarket near you on the Peet’s Cafe Domingo, give it a try, and if you like it, go for the 96-count box – it’s worth it!

Read more reviews at Amazon.com

13. Newman’s Own Organic Special Decaf

The Newman’s Own Organic Special Decaf Blend might arguably be their most tasty K-Cup thus far, deservedly so! The blend delivers a bright and delicious taste mixed with a slight tartness. The coffee is roasted with hints of nuts, chocolate, and banana. Overall, this K-Cup will give you just the boldness you are looking for with a unique flavor component. 

Specifications

  • Medium Roast
  • Notes of nuts, chocolate, and banana
  • Decaffeinated
  • Kosher-Certified

Sample Customer Review… I can only imbibe in decaf drinks since caffeine is a migraine trigger for me. I’ve tried many brands and flavors of decaf and this one is the best. I dislike a chemical-like aftertaste in decaf brews. Newman’s Own has no aftertaste and is not bitter, it tastes like regular coffee. I also like the fact it is organic. It is truly a medium roast–I’m not fond of the very strong, dark roasts. If you want bold, this not the coffee for you. But it isn’t weak either. Very smooth with cream added. I even drink this black with a bit of sugar and find it is smooth with good coffee flavor and no acidity.

Review found at Keurig.com

14. Barista Prima Coffeehouse Italian Roast

Would you classify yourself as a dark roast lover? Well, the Barista Prima Coffeehouse Italian Roast is compiled of a bold, full-bodied cup of coffee that embodies the tradition of an authentic Italian dark roast. The last item on the list, this k-cup ties to European inspired coffee delivers a strong punch of flavor and smokiness with hints of ripe fruit, berries, and dark chocolate. The Barista Prima Coffeehouse line was created with the intent to create a darker and bolder K-Cup, which has made it quite popular. Every pod packs more flavor and grounds into every brew over typical K-Cups. Overall, this K-Cup is a dark roast lover’s dream. 

Specifications

  • Dark Roast
  • Hints of chocolate, ripe fruit, & smokiness
  • Caffeinated
  • Kosher-Certified

Sample Customer Review… Let’s start by saying that I’ve been ordering this product for over 2 years now and I’ve never received a bad cup! Additionally, I’ve never gotten tired of the Italian Roast flavor. It’s dark and bold, with an almost espresso-y finish. Definitely geared toward your strong coffee lovers out there. If you’re a breakfast blend or other light roast person, would not recommend this coffee for you. For medium and dark roast fans, you will not be disappointed.

I’ve tried about 8 or 9 different Kcup brands over the years and they all pale in comparison to Barista Prima. Also, the price is quite reasonable for the amount you get. 5 out of 5 stars, would highly recommend!

Read more reviews at Amazon.com

Things to Consider Before Buying

If you are brand new to the world of Keurig or are just wanting to find a new K-Cup coffee flavor to try, you should take into account these characteristics before purchasing. 

Roasts

Whether you are new to learning how to differentiate the different types of coffee, or just need a refresher, it is of the utmost importance that you understand the roasting process. With each type of roast, the coffee beans are roasted at a different temperature for a different amount of time. The varying roasts differentiate certain coffee characteristics, such as bitterness, acidity, amount of caffeine, body, color, and the overall coffee flavor. Roasts typically range from light, medium, and dark, but sometimes bold or even extra bold. 

Light roasts are typically sweeter and contain more flavor components and caffeination than the other kind of roasts. Coffee beans used to craft lighter roasts are usually roasted at temperatures between 350 to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. Following the roasting process, the crafted blend has a low oil content and a high acidic content. 

Medium roasts provide balanced acidity, as well as a balanced body. Hence, they generally offer a richer flavor, in comparison to light roasts, and have smaller traces of caffeine. 

Dark roasts, on the other hand, typically release flavors of the deepest notes and tones. Darker roasts possess fuller-bodied roasts, along with a richer, bolder, and bitter flavor. Due to the longer roast times, dark roasts contain very low amounts of caffeine and generally contain more oils from the coffee beans themselves. 

Blends

Coffee blends are a combination of two or more coffee beans differing in origin. The main concept behind blends is to combine different types of beans of the best quality to create a well-rounded, balanced coffee taste. Most coffee blends are crafted to be complementary with milk if you so choose to pair them together. One key advantage of a blend is that they are typically not quite as overpowering as a single type of bean. Blends also provide more consistency and forgiveness over beans of single origin. 

Ordinarily, single-origin coffee is roasted as either a light or medium roast to maximize its unique flavor potential. But the darker you roast, the bigger the risk of losing any unique flavor components, and the bitterness will start to replace the initial flavors. Therefore, blends can allow for stronger flavors if done right! 

Some blends include breakfast blends, flavored blends, and decaf blends. 

Breakfast blends are crafted as light-to-medium roasts that are low in acidity and contain rounded flavors. Since most coffee lovers prefer to start their day off with a wholesome cup of joe, a breakfast blend is created exactly for the morning.

Flavored blends are often roasted in combination with a mixture of nuts, herbs, spices, or varying aromas that offer more flavor to the coffee beans during the roasting process. Infusing the coffee beans with extra flavors allows for a wide variety of different brews that will be sure to impress even the pickiest coffee drinkers. 

Decaf blends, on the other hand, is coffee that has been decaffeinated by at least 97%, which leaves approximately 1-3% of the remaining caffeine. This blend is most helpful for coffee lovers who might face limitations, such as pregnancy, nursing, or other medical issues inhibiting a high caffeine intake. 

Brand

Among the many K-Cup options we listed, all are very well known and reliable in terms of quality and flavor! But maybe one brand does not meet your expectations or maybe your favorite coffee brand does not have any K-Cups?

Well, some smaller coffee brands may not be established enough to sell K-Cups within the coffee market, but the good news is that we have a solution for you! Reusable K-Cups allow you to brew any ground coffee you want, providing a wider selection of coffee for your Keurig machine. 

Price

In terms of purchasing K-Cups, someone’s spending allowance may vary. Factors, such as quantity, quality, and brand directly affect the price of each package. For the most part, the higher the quantity or quality, the higher the price. However, several of the K-Cups we listed are affordable, yet, also high in quality. Thus, you should make sure to research which blend and brand closely align with your price and quality expectations. 

Conclusion 

To conclude, when choosing the best K Cup coffee for you, you should take into account what roasts, blends, and levels of caffeine best match your coffee expectations. But don’t be afraid to branch out and try the many different kinds of K-Cup coffee, because we know you will just love most of the different options we listed. Whether you are looking for a new everyday favorite or are wanting more variety, we hope our list helps! 


Related Articles

Featured Articles

Written By Caleb MacDonald and Alexis Enderle

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.