With an oversaturation of drip coffee makers on the market, it can be challenging to determine which one will work the best for you. But luckily, you are in the right place as the best SCAA coffee makers (Specialty Coffee Association of America) are high-quality machines that are ranked superior due to the quality of both the coffee maker as a whole and the coffee it brews.
The SCAA considers many aspects regarding their strict guidelines, including the water temperature, brewing time, and the capability to brew according to the SGA Golden recommendations. Therefore, meaning you will not have to take into account those guidelines. But instead, we recommend you consider taking a look at the differing features, such as the varying brew times, capacity, settings, and style of carafe (thermal or glass). Then next, pinpoint which of those aspects matter to you most. In the following list, we give an in-depth review of our top 10 picks for the best SCAA Coffee makers, and one of them will hopefully be the right fit for you!
Top 10 Best SCAA Coffee Makers
1. Bonavita BV1900TS Coffee Maker
The Bonavita BV1900TS is nothing short of a great coffee maker but without all of the extra bells and whistles. The Bonavita is one of the most affordable SCAA-certified machines on the market. No one should have to sacrifice the quality of their morning cup of coffee due to budget constraints. The Bonavita coffee maker could be the solution for you.
The Bonavita BV1900TS features a larger showerhead that gives a uniform extraction and excellent levels of saturation. Thus, enabling the coffee grounds to bloom before each brew. The machine also brews very quickly, brewing 8 cups in only 6 minutes. But an even better feature from this Bonavita model is the stainless steel carafe that keeps the coffee hot for up to 2 hours following the brew.
Another reason why we love this machine is how practical it is for at-home users. The Bonavita coffee maker is easy to clean. Since it’s BPA-free, you can throw it right in the dishwasher and not have to worry about it. But one area it might lack is functionality. The Bonavita lacks the programmable feature that many avid coffee lovers adore. But depending on the importance of this feature to you, we do not think this is a deal-breaker. The Bonavita is also smaller in size, making it a perfect addition to any kitchen counter.
In the end, the Bonavita offers a lot of bang for your buck for a drip coffee machine that meets the high-quality standards of the SCAA certification.
- 12.4in x 6.8in x 12.2in
- 8 cup capacity
- 6-minute brew
- Materials: stainless steel & BPA-free plastic
Sample Customer Review… This is the best coffee maker ever and I have tried many, including the excellent Technivorm Moccamaster KBT 741. What makes this one unique is the flexibility to brew exactly the way you want. This is enabled by the brew basket, which is a super simple flat bottom basket that does not actually attach to the coffee maker. It sits on top of the carafe and slides under the excellent drip head, which disperses the perfectly hot water across the contents of the filter. There is no stopper on the bottom of the brew basket, which means it does not have to be used with the carafe. It can sit on top of another container, like a Yeti 20oz Rambler Tumbler. Simply adjust how much coffee is put into the filter. The pre-soak feature is very clever and also works exactly as advertised, with an initial slow pour of hot water to soak the grinds, and then the remainder of the pour. I highly recommend this coffee brewer.Read more reviews at Amazon.com.
2. Braun BrewSense Drip Coffee Maker
The Braun BrewSense has a sleek design that’s easy to fit in anyone’s kitchen. This coffeemaker is programmable 24/7 with an automatic shut-off. Another good design feature is the easy-to-view clock. The control panel is easy to use and the cord can easily be hidden. That being said, there are a lot of buttons so it might be useful to study the instructions.
The coffee itself has a lot of settings. The water level can be chosen from an 11 oz mug all the way to 12 cups. The water event saturates the beans to create a rich aroma. It has PureFlavor Technology to ensure precise and accurate brew time and temperature. The most exciting feature is the gold coffee filter instead of a paper filter. This allows for essential oils to reach the coffee. The charcoal filter cleans the water allowing for the coffee to be its most creamy and flavorful self. The clean-up is simple with some parts being self-cleaning while the others are dishwasher safe.
- 7.9 x 7.9 x 14.2 inches
- Weight is 7.4 pounds
- Brew capacity of 12 cups
- Stainless Steel
Sample Customer Review… We purchased this Braun coffee maker over six months ago as a replacement for a similar Cuisinart model that quit working. We love this Braun model even better than our more expensive Cuisinart! It has temperature and brew strength settings which are features we wanted since we like our coffee very hot. It brews quickly and keeps the coffee hot until the timer shuts it off. It’s relatively quiet and doesn’t spew coffee grounds all over the lid like the Cuisinart used to. We also like the sleek stainless steel design and the pushbuttons work great. We rarely clean the exterior with more than hot water and a microfiber cloth. We run a cycle of white vinegar through it monthly to keep it clean. We have had no problem with the letters rubbing off the control buttons like some of the reviews stated. But, we don’t use harsh chemicals to clean it either. Overall, we are very happy with this Braun coffee maker and will definitely buy it again when this one quits.Read more reviews at Amazon.com.
3. Technivorm Moccamaster 59616
The Technivorm Moccamaster 59616 coffee maker is a popular machine that leans a bit more toward the pricier side but is worth it!
The Technivorm Moccamaster delivers all the standard features, along with a few luxuries that enhance the overall quality. It has a one-touch operation, the automatic power off, and the automatic drip-stop. But what takes the Technivorm Moccamaster to the next level is the copper heating element, a fast brew time (4-6 minutes), a uniform saturation from the 9-hole outlet arm, and an advanced hot plate that delivers an even taste and maintains the desired temperature.
The machine also features a larger brew capacity, brewing up to 10 cups of coffee in just minutes! Overall, this machine could be worth the investment if you are willing to spend a little extra on the advanced features!
- 14in x 12.75in x 6.5in
- 10 cup capacity
- 4-6 minute brew
- Auto-Off at 100 minutes
- Materials: metal & plastic
Sample Customer Review… I decided that I wanted the best coffee maker out there because I was tired of Keurig and the slime that builds up in the tank… no matter how much you descale it. After reading many reviews and watching America’s Test Kitchen reviews on the best coffee makers, I went with this one. So happy that I did.
Besides the beauty of this machine, it brews quickly and at a perfect temp, consistently. I have also noticed that because it brews a perfect pot, it saves you money by not using as much ground coffee. It extracts the most flavor out of the beans and you don’t need as many tablespoons of the grounds. It is never bitter, just perfect. I also must recommend the best burr grinder to you as well. It is the Baratza Encore. I have never had one that grinds the beans, whichever size you choose, consistently. Wow… so impressed with both products. If you love coffee, treat yourself to the best. I don’t buy coffee out nearly as much now, which also saves me money. I do the cold brew (with the Gvode cold brewer… awesome) and now the best hot coffee maker on the market. There really is a difference.Read more reviews at Amazon.com.
4. Ninja Specialty Coffee Maker
Are you a coffee drink that loves variety? Well, then perhaps you will consider getting the Ninja Specialty Coffee Maker. It is SCAA-certified and then some. The machine has six sizes, including a single cup and up to a full carafe, and four brew styles, including classic, iced, rich, and specialty. You might be wondering what a specialty brew is. Well, the specialty brew option makes a rich concentrate from the coffee. While it is not espresso in a technical sense, it is close.
Ninja has several different coffee machines, but this one ranks supreme in brew quality. But this is not just any ordinary drip coffee machine. The Ninja Specialty Coffee Maker comes with a frother that froths or warms up the milk while the coffee is brewing. Overall, if you are looking for a delicious cup of coffee with a twist, but are not necessarily looking to change the coffee brewing settings, then you will love this Ninja.
- 11.99in x 8.75in x 15.04in
- 10 cup capacity
- 4-8 minute brew
- Materials: plastic & metal
Sample Customer Review… I have been on the hunt for the perfect coffee maker for a long time. I wanted something that was reliable, quick, with multiple different brew options. This ticks all of the boxes. I am absolutely in love with this machine. The different size options, the different brews, the ease of cleaning. It does everything I could possibly want. I don’t feel like any of the bells and whistles are going to waste, either, because it is all practical. Probably my favorite feature is the option for brewing over ice. But what’s also nice is that if I’m in the mood for hot coffee but my hubby is in the mood for iced, we don’t have to agree because we can just quickly brew our own individual portions. This coffee maker quickly became our pride and joy. Stop hemming and hawing and just buy it, because it’s 100000% worth it. Yeah, it has a larger footprint and yes you can’t fit your entire hand in the carafe to clean it. The trade-off is worth it though, I promise. Get a bottle brush, clear off the counter space and stop living like uncivilized slime that compromised on their coffee.Read more reviews at Amazon.com.
5. Breville Precision Brewer Coffee Maker
If you classify yourself as a more experienced coffee enthusiast, then the Breville Precision Brewer Coffee Maker could be the perfect option for you! With this particular model, you will be able to determine whether or not your coffee is either over or under-extracted. If you like to make minor adjustments to reach the best cup of joe, then working with this machine will be a treat!
The Breville Precision Brewer has PID control, enabling you to control the temperature according to your preference with precision and ease! You can also choose from three different flow rates for the water, which will alter the brew time. But if you do not want to change your settings each time, you can also program your settings to match your ideal preferences.
The Breville Precision Brewer brings the best of both worlds! It gives you total control if you want it. But if you do not feel like experimenting on a given day, you can use one of their preset modes. The machine offers several different presets, including fast, strong, iced, cold brew, and the gold cup. The gold cup is the ideal choice because it alters the temperature and brew time to meet the SCAA standards.
However, we like that you can also make options like cold brew, which most machines do not offer. The coffee maker also features the Breville steep & release valve. The valve allows you to remove the carafe with no mess mid-brew to pour a cup in a hurry.
- 12.4in x 6.7in x 15.7 in
- 12 cup capacity
- 8-minute brew
- Materials: stainless steel & plastic
Sample Customer Review… I’ve had this coffee maker for about a month now. I was skeptical, researching higher-end coffee makers proved difficult, with lots of mixed reviews and complaints. When the price dropped on Breville I picked one up. So far it has exceeded my expectations. Coffee taste has been amazing, it really outshined our cheap drip maker with clean, hot, distinct tasting coffee. The machine has been easy to use and maintain, I often fill a few inches above the max fill line to make a bigger pot. The stainless steel carafe provided is of excellent quality, it keeps hot coffee steaming hot for many hours. Just make sure you rinse some hot water in the stainless steel carafe before you make your pot of coffee. A cold carafe won’t keep your coffee hot for very long. Other than that I just hope this machine maintains its quality for a long time. I’m very pleased with the taste and quality of this coffee maker.Read more reviews at Amazon.com.
6. BUNN Heat n Brew Coffeemaker
The BUNN Heat n Brew is one of the simplest models to use on this list. It is very easy to use. One of the main attractions is how simple it is to program the water temperature. As the SCAA notes, water temperature is one of the main pillars of a good brew. This model has a digital thermometer that directly measures the water temperature. The thermometer is quick to view and easy to adjust. From there, the water evenly saturates the grounds through a 6 stream head to give your coffee the fullest flavor possible.
This model sets itself apart from the pack with a durable glass carafe. You cannot move the coffee pot until it is done brewing, but this brewer is programmable so it can be ready by the time you wake up. The carafe is drip-free because the lid arcs the coffee into the mug while the rest wicks back into the carafe. To ensure your satisfaction, it has a three-year warranty.
- Weighs 8.5 pounds
- 9.7 x 8.7 x 16.3 inches
- Wattage Output of 1300 watts
- Stainless Steel
Sample Customer Review… Finally, coffee that tastes like real brewed coffee! I’ve used Bunn machines for many years, but with the advent of the Keurig machines, I kind of left the Bunn behind and moved on. I have been using the k-cups with several different machines over the past several years and basically forgot how good real coffee used to be. I do buy coffee beans online and grind my own, and also will use the actual k-cups, which I’m not a fan of. The Bunn is definitely not as quick as a Keurig machine, but while I’m preparing breakfast, I start the brewing, and it’s done within 5 minutes since I measure out 24oz of water; so about 5 cups of coffee on the pot’s cup indicator. Haven’t made a full pot yet, but I’m sure it will take about 8-10 minutes. Easy cleanup too. Brews so nice and hot. It is a tall machine, like 16″ so it does not fit under my cabinets on the countertop. It actually just meets the bottom of the cabinet. But It works out fine for me as I have a lot of space. It is also a nice-designed unit. I haven’t used the programming yet, but I’m sure it works. I don’t have the need to auto-start the machine in the morning.Read more reviews at Amazon.com.
7. Ninja Hot and Cold Brew
This coffee maker is more than a coffee maker, it has the ability to make tea, over-ice drinks, flavorful coffee, and frothy specialty brews. This is a pod-free machine and uses baskets instead. The baskets are separate for tea and coffee to make sure there is no crossing of the flavors. This is perfect for the buyer who enjoys a variety of drinks. You can also brew a variety of sizes such as a single cup or a half carafe.
There is a milk frother right on the machine to make hot or cold milk into the perfect addition to a cappuccino or matcha latte. To accommodate all these different options there are 5 different styles of brewing: specialty, cold brew, classic, rich, and over ice. Since there are no pods, this allows for any brand of ground coffee or loose leaf tea to be used. This coffee maker is perfect for the person who enjoys a multitude of drinks.
- 11.81 x 10.01 x 15 inches
- Weight of 1 pound
- 10 cup capacity
- Made of plastic, metal, and rubber
Sample Customer Review… I purchased this for my birthday – I’d been wanting a coffee maker that could make single-serve without pods or k-cups, and this fit the bill – also didn’t hurt that the reviews were pretty phenomenal. So I pulled the trigger, and I’m glad I did. This coffee maker is amazing. I’m a hardcore coffee drinker, but got spoiled on the convenience of k-cups…too expensive in the long run for someone who drinks as much coffee as I do, and I wanted to curb my spending on specialty drinks (e.g. flat whites anyone?). The Ninja does all of this and more. It brews a great cup OR a great pot of coffee…I’m pretty impressed with the flavor on just a pot brewed on Classic. The Rich setting is awesome for some stronger brews when I add cream, and I’ve used the Speciality to make my own flat whites…which taste the same if not better than buying them in a coffee shop. Also, love the variety of sizes – and omg the scoop that comes with it! It’s got a holder for the scoop. This fits my nerd personality to a tee. I love how it comes with the permanent filter – super easy to clean up. The quick start guide gives you all the lowdowns on how to get started. From someone who is incredibly picky and hard to impress when it comes to design and usability…this coffee maker is perfect. I haven’t had it for very long so I’m hoping its durability also impresses with time. Anyway, if you want a phenomenal coffee maker, this is the one for you, highly recommend – worth the money!Read more reviews at Amazon.com.
8. Cuisinart CPO-850 Coffee Brewer
The Cuisinart CPO-850 Coffee Brewer is a good option if you need some extra help in the morning, whether you are in a hurry or can barely keep your eyes open. The main focal point of this particular model is the programmability aspect.
You can access all the program functions on the large LCD screen. With the 24-hour turn-on function, you can set the machine to auto-brew for anytime within 24 hours. Another favorable program function is changing settings such as temperature (hot or extra hot), flavor strength (mild, medium, & bold), and bloom mode to maximize the extraction. This Cuisinart model gives you the ability to customize your cup of coffee to your exact preferences with ease.
The Cuisinart CPO-850 comes with a laser-etched permanent stainless steel filter, a charcoal water filter, and a #4 paper filter pack. The stainless steel filter is better than a paper filter because it will not absorb any oils from the coffee grounds and instead will go right into your cup. Then, allowing for a bolder & thicker flavor. If we haven’t seemed to impress you yet, wait! This model also has a brew-pause feature and a self-cleaning mode, adding even more convenience. Right when we thought Cuisinart couldn’t make it more convenient, they did it! Overall, this machine is a fantastic option if you are looking to make your coffee-making experience even just the slightest bit more convenient.
- 14.5in x 13.75in x 9.5in
- 8 cup capacity
- 7-minute brew
- Materials: stainless steel & plastic
Sample Customer Review… I almost passed this coffee maker when looking for a replacement due to some of the less favorable reviews. I like the brand and have had products from Cuisinart in the past so I gave it a shot. I’m very satisfied with this purchase of this coffee maker. It brews an excellent cup of coffee for a homebrew system using standard grinds, nothing fancy. The stainless steel carafe in my experience thus far has worked like a charm and keeps the coffee temp long enough to enjoy the coffee without having to guzzle it down. I didn’t experience any of the messy drip problems that others commented about, just take your time pouring it out. The display is big and easy to operate and the overall appearance of the coffee maker is very nice also. I only wish this would’ve been available in a 12 cup version. Overall I love this coffee maker and definitely recommend this.Read more reviews at Amazon.com.
9. OXO BREW Coffee Maker
The OXO BREW coffee maker is perfect for those who want something a bit more advance than the typical drip coffee machine. The OXO BREW utilizes a high-tech microprocessor-controlled brew cycle that produces up to 9 cups of coffee, similar to the pour-over method.
The included double-insulated thermal carafe can maintain the coffee at a high temperature for multiple hours, making this machine perfect for anyone who enjoys several cups of coffee throughout the day. The coffee maker also maintains the water temperature between 197.6˚F to 204.8˚F to maximize the coffee extraction process, which the SCAA claims are the best range for brewing.
Unlike many other coffee machines, the OXO’s showerhead properly moistens and evenly distributes the water across the coffee grounds for the best bloom. The OXO machine brews a flavor that is well balanced and consistent, no matter the desired quantity. But not only does it produce delicious tasting coffee, but it is also easy to use! The LED interface indicates the freshness and the status of the coffee maker.
The OXO machine also delivers convenience by allowing you to program a wake-up time up to 24 hours after setting it. All you have to do is select how much coffee you want to make, and the cup will be ready for you whenever you have it set! Overall, this machine is quite innovative, stylish, and it meets the mark in all areas!
- 15in x 8.3in x 17.2in
- 9 cup capacity
- 7-8 minute brew
- Materials: stainless steel & plastic
Sample Customer Review… I did a lot of research before I bought this coffee maker, and I couldn’t be happier. First off, it keeps the coffee hot for a very long time. We make our coffee extremely early in the morning (like before 5 a.m.) and there are times when I’ve come back for coffee at 3:00 in the afternoon, and the remaining coffee in the pot is still warm! The pot itself is what keeps the coffee hot/warm as the part it sits on does not heat up. That’s the beauty of this machine. The lid screws on nice and tight so that the coffee pours in one nice stream (note: if you don’t tighten it all the way, the coffee may pour in two separate streams, but then you just give the lid an extra turn and all is well). Easy to operate, one-button activation. I’m so glad I put the effort into researching this because it paid off! You won’t be disappointed!Read more reviews at Amazon.com.
10. KitchenAid KCM0802OB Pour-Over Brewer
The KitchenAid Coffee Brewer is perfect for anyone who wants a coffee machine replicating a brew from a manual pour-over without the hassle. Utilizing the pour-over function is a great way to try new beans. If you like trying out different roasts or blends, as well as discovering taste profiles, then this machine could be the one for you! It is one of the few SCAA Coffee Makers that offers settings specifically for roasts during the brew. The flavor components are slightly adjusted depending on whether you indicate that you want a medium or dark roast. In doing so, you will be able to taste subtle flavors across the different roasts.
This KitchenAid Coffee Brewer features a productive heating element that maintains the water temperature between the range of 198˚F and 204˚F while brewing. During brew, the visual display makes it easy to follow along with each step. This KitchenAid machine also features a 24-hour turn-on feature, as mentioned in a couple of other coffee machines on our list. Overall, this machine delivers delicious tasting coffee through the pour-over method while also providing convenience and ease of use.
- 11.3in x 8.7in x 15.1in
- 8 cups capacity
- Materials: plastic
Sample Customer Review… After doing much research, and inviting myself over to friends’ and colleagues’ houses to sample coffee from various makers, I settled on the KitchenAid pour-over, and now, one month in, I am not regretting my purchase. I have learned that there are so many important steps in making a great cup of coffee and the brewer is what brings the steps together and puts out the finished product. The pleasing to the eye KitchenAid blends well with my other black appliances and is easy to use and easy to clean. Set to medium roast, in about 6 minutes I have 8 cups of full-bodied coffee ready to drink that will burn my tongue if I drink it too fast. The coffee will stay warm for an hour as the carafe sits on a warming plate and never tastes burnt or overdone. The unit is tall so I have to slide it out from under my cabinet to fill the water tank and you do have to be careful pouring the water into the rather small opening. The carafe is easy to use, however, and never spills. Very happy with this sleek, efficient pour-over!Read more reviews at Amazon.com.
Buying Guide: Thing to Consider When Purchasing an SCAA Coffee Maker
When considering the features of these coffee makers, the ability to program a time to make coffee is attractive to a lot of buyers. This does not come cheap. Programmability usually makes the model more expensive. If this coffee maker is going in an office to be used by many people then maybe programming is not a necessary feature. It is completely worth it to a customer who likes to have their coffee brewed before they wake up. There are simpler models that require the turn of a dial, but some have more intense software menus.
SCAA Golden Cup
One certification of an SCAA coffee maker is the coffee volume. The brew basket must follow what the SCA calls the golden cup ratio. For every 55 grams of coffee grounds there needs to be 1 liter of water. The temperature of the water heated must be between 195 and 205 degrees F. The heating is a clear certification of SCAA standards so looking for a coffee maker that heats in this range will ensure certification. Another thing tested is the strength of the cup. If the model works correctly, it will even saturate all the beans, creating an even extraction.
There is a lot of debate between the hot plate and the carafe. The hot plate has been known to burn the coffee, so a carafe is a valuable option. Hot plates have also been known to be fire hazards, so the carafe is the safer option. It is vacuum-sealed between the walls so the heat is kept inside. It is slightly complicated because of its temperature requirements. It must be hotter than 176 degrees F, but cooler than 185 degrees F.
Options for Brewing
A good cup of coffee relies on the grounds to water ratio according to the SCAA. Depending on the model of your coffee maker, regulating the water is either a software setting or a manual experience. If there are too many grounds, the coffee can become bitter and there will be sediment in the cup.
There are lots of other options such as making their coffee hotter or colder, stronger or weaker, etc. There will be a manual in the box, but these are very important to research before purchasing.
In the end, getting a drip coffee brewer that is approved by the Specialty Coffee Association of America not only ensures that you will get a high-quality cup of coffee daily, but these machines will be sure to last you a long time. Overall, we hope that our in-depth reviews and product descriptions help you decipher which of our top picks for the best SCAA coffee makers will work the best for you. Whether you are looking for advanced brew technology, programmable features, or simplicity, one of these will be bound to meet or exceed your expectations.
- Best 4 Cup Coffee Maker
- Best Cappuccino Maker
- Best Dual Coffee Maker
- Best Pour Over Coffee Makers
- Best Keurig Coffee Makers
- Best BPA Free Coffee Maker
- Best Fully Automatic Coffee Machine
- Best Cold Brew Maker
- Best Coffee Makers For Your RV
- Best Camping Coffee Makers
- Best Thermal Coffee Maker
- Best Siphon Coffee Maker
Written by Caleb MacDonald and Caoilinn Turner